Home

Advertisement

Customize
 
 
29 May 2008 @ 09:27 am
a few thoughts about gay marriage  
This may sound funny and I'm sorry for implicating my friends list, but I was kinda' upset more people didn't say congratulations when gay marriage was legalized in California. It's not like I'm mad at anyone, I'm just surprised. The California victory is monumental. I suppose it may be easy to overlook and take for granted the impact of marriage rights when they're a given in your own life.

I live in a community that has had almost an entire generation wiped away from the AIDS pandemic. In my community, many men bolster the stereotype that gays sleep around and can't commit. I think--no, I believe quite strongly that a significant portion of the gay community's sexual and relationship-oriented indiscretions can be explained by a lack of formal and recognized legal commitment. When gay marriage ban advocates talk about the destructive habits of gay men outlined above, I find their arguments utterly ironic because legalized gay marriage would help challenge many of the lifestyle choices they find so unhealthy and deplorable. (I'm not saying that I think these things are deplorable, I only mean to point out the paradox.)

After gay marriage was legalized in California, I thought of my new potential and weeped, literally weeped. A husband? Kids? People to take care of me and love me as I grow old. Growing up, I never had a future. I never dared to dream of life past 30. I'm almost able to do dream of these things. I'll exhale after the November election.

I normally love watching presidential election results. To me, they're like the Olympics: they happen once every four years and I normally cheer for the underdog. This year will be a particularly difficult year for me to sit through the results. In November, a simple majority of California's population will determine whether or not gay marriages will continue to happen in my state. Watching the vote results on TV will be heartbreaking, regardless of the outcome. I can't sit and watch these numbers go up and down, numbers that affirm and negate my humanity, my rights, my future. While, in the state legislature, it takes a super majority (2/3rds) to amend the state constitution, the document can be amended by a SIMPLE MAJORITY of the popular vote. I'm dumbfounded by anyone who has the audacity to suggest that the rights of less than 10% of people should be put into the hands of a SIMPLE MAJORITY of the population in a popular vote, even if that simple majority contradicts the will of the state legislature, governor, and state supreme court.

Soon after gay marriage was legalized in California, I hear a conservative pundit ask Dan Savage if he planned to raise his kids gay. It's a stupid, cliche, shameful, and ridiculous argument to ask gay parents. The obvious retort: "If all kids copied the sexuality of their parents, Savage would be straight." I've given a lot of thought to this pundit's question and have made some sense out of his idiocy. Of course some straight folks think that gay parents will raise their kids to be gay. They probably think this because our culture rigorously raises children to be straight! Heterosexuality is taught in almost every U.S. institution, from churches and the Boy Scouts to public schools and sports clubs. Gay children face the threat of being ostracized and cut off from their families. Gay parents have gone through the burdens of a socialization that does not coincide with their natural inclinations. Because of this, they know the importance of not pushing a sexual identity down the throat of a child. Still, the routinization of HETEROSEXUALITY is inescapable, even for the children of gay men and women.

I write all this today because I was (and in many ways continue to be) a kid who never saw my future reflected in TV shows and movies. "Happily ever after" never included me. But I'm starting to believe that it can. Despite my fears, I think gay marriage will prevail in the California's November election. I believe that, with all its faults, marriage will have tremendously positive implications for gay men and women. I believe.
 
 
( Post a new comment )
coffee stained boy[info]freetaco on May 29th, 2008 05:11 pm (UTC)
i was very happy over here in my own little way when I heard the news. A friend hipped me that New York's guv says he wants the state (and thus state officials) to recognize gay marriages that have occurred where they are legal, such as in Canada and California.

i am very happy for you, ragan. and happy for everyone, really. equal protection under the law means everybody.

lv_prosewriter: Hair 1[info]lv_prosewriter on May 30th, 2008 05:07 am (UTC)
Yes!--
I was going to say this. Apparently Gov. Patterson also said he hoped it would be totally legal soon and that people would thus stay in NY, rather than move to CA. He wants Niagara Falls to become a gay honeymoon spot for the 21st century. (honestly--they really said this on NPR.


Victor Infante[info]ocvictor on May 29th, 2008 06:39 pm (UTC)
I apologize if I didn't make some noise -- been a bit distracted lately. That being said, we've had it here in Mass. for two years. Sometimes it's easy to forget that we're the only state gay marriage has gone into effect in.

(Although I can categorically state that, no matter what the crazies say, the world doesn't end when gays are allowed to marry, and indeed, God blessed us with victories for both the Red Sox and The Patriots immediately afterward, so all California sports fans should realize they need to be on your side. :)
lv_prosewriter[info]lv_prosewriter on May 30th, 2008 05:09 am (UTC)
true but
I heard on NPR today that Massachusetts won't let people from states where it is illegal come there to get married. I went to my co-workers wedding in Connecticut. I thought it was legal there?
Thomas Lopez, Jr[info]hephaestionaz on May 29th, 2008 06:49 pm (UTC)
Given what has happened there previously I'm waiting for actual marriages to occur before I start shedding tears of joy.

The court decision was an important one, but I don't see it as bulletproof, and hopefully the referendum to change the state constitution will not gain much traction.
shannon: i love giraffes.[info]itsemonotelmo on May 29th, 2008 07:22 pm (UTC)
these are my thoughts exactly. it's a nice step forward but there are still many more to be made.
jonesysnout[info]jonesysnout on May 29th, 2008 07:07 pm (UTC)
Well, well...
Ragan, I adore you.

I am so thankful for you to have the chance to breathe.

lemme know when you're out here so I can scratch your arms.

xo
karen g[info]nerak_g on May 29th, 2008 07:59 pm (UTC)
There are so many waiting
it makes me want to punch any R/conservative (especially with a divorce history) in the face every time I hear their tripe.Ohyes, it is so sacred and so valued that we have find-a-wife TV lottery shows about it.

Meanwhile, acquaintances of mine who have been together for 11,12 or more years wait....the rest of us dream...and
one state at a time is sooooooo slow.

Tony Jackson[info]tonyjackson on May 29th, 2008 08:52 pm (UTC)
It's interesting that you mention this because...
I actually thought of congratulating you and many of my gay friend (but, I thought of you in particular.) In the end, I didn't for a few of reasons.

The first and definitely the most predominate reason was that I am a coward when it comes to social etiquette. I mean by this that I usually avoid situations where I don't know what is acceptable conduct. While part of me wanted to put up a blog congratulating you, there was another part that wondered if it would be the equivalent of you wishing me Happy Kwanzaa. Trust me a lot of people do wish me a Happy Kwanzaa and it is as comical as it is sad. So, I didn't want to be the person, who at the mention of any thing remotely to do with Gay people turns to my token gay friends and says, "So Ragan, what do you think?" And sure by the shere number of gay people that I know, you really can't qualify as my "token" gay friend, but you know what I mean.

The second reason that I didn't congratulate was that I know that you are as tragically single as I am. I recognize the significance of you having the right to get married, but I have had the right for 35 years and it has not helped my prospects. To me, someone reminding me of my right to marry would highlight the pitifully slim chance that I will ever find someone to marry. Wow, am I really so self-centered that I bring everything back to how I would feel? Anyway, my point is, you have to imagine me doing my best Jerry Springer ghetto girl guest impression with my neck rolling and my index finger wagging when I say, "Girlfriend, I will congratulate you when you actually get a man!!!"

Lastly, I didn't congratulate you for the same reason that I don't congratulate people on the 4th of July for their country's victory over the British. It's my country too. The fact that we live in a country that to this day openly can still legislate discrimination is a pox on all of us (with a burden that is suffered by the targeted minority.) My right to vote, as a black man, is not something that just I should celebrate, but something that we should all celebrate. It means that country is a better place than it was before I could vote. And I don't mean to diminish your personal victory, but I just think that the black Civil Rights movement only began to gain traction once it ceased to be a only struggle for the black community and became a struggle for the nation as whole. So my question is, when the Gay Marriage Ban was struck down, why didn't you congratulate me?

Just joking! Congratulate Ragan!
lv_prosewriter: Hair 1[info]lv_prosewriter on May 30th, 2008 05:21 am (UTC)
I know what yhou mean...
I said something to my gay co-worker (also my friend), but felt a bit just as you say.
coffee stained boy[info]freetaco on May 30th, 2008 02:32 pm (UTC)
Re: It's interesting that you mention this because...
Dude, Happy Kwanzaa. It's this weekend, right?
Monique[info]mixmaster_mo on May 30th, 2008 08:09 am (UTC)
In my defense, I haven't really been on this thing. But I was there when the papers announced it and screamed "Hell FUCKIN yeah!" quite loudly as people stared at me like I was crazy.

And then I looked at my husband and said, "I'm so glad we're moving here."

I really hope it impacts the rest of the country.
Diane Fleming[info]dfleming on May 30th, 2008 08:29 pm (UTC)
yeah, i should've said something, but to be honest, i find it really difficult to keep up-to-date with gay-marriage status, both in terms of its denial and acceptance in various states. that's no excuse - of course it should be important to me. but that's my honest reason for not paying attention...and i turned bitter in last election in texas. lots of gay people i know didn't go vote and the texas state constitution was altered to define marriage as between a man and a woman.
@!d# ★★★: don't fuck with me i'm invincible[info]busterfriendly on May 31st, 2008 01:58 am (UTC)
I, for one, was pretty fucking stoked when I heard the news. I grew up in California and I had just turned 18 when the "protect marriage" proposition 22 was put up for vote. Some bigot on my street plastered our neighborhood with signs that said that horrible slogan, and I was crushed when the proposition passed. That was my first experience as a voter and it was a very depressing election for me.

I'm in Arizona now, but when the news came out about them (finally) finding that bullshit unconstitutional, I felt an overwhelming sense of joy, but also a pang of homesickness. I miss California. Hopefully I'll get accepted into a MA program back home so that I can come back. I've had enough of this red state. I'll come back to California any day, governator and all. I will also be crossing my fingers that the election in November turns out in our favor because no matter how you word it, discrimination hurts everyone. Our community needs this more than anything right now.
 
 

Advertisement

Customize